Mexican-Style Hot Chocolate Recipe (2024)

Bermuda shorts with boots, the words “fat free” and “sour cream” . . . . some things just don’t go together, you know? While at first glance it may seem that chocolate and chili powder fall into that category, my friend Jenny’s Rustic Mayan Truffles prove otherwise.

I discoveredthem years ago while rummaging through her sitefor a soup recipe, and they opened up a new world of flavor for me.

Mexican hot chocolate is by far my favorite way to enjoy this unique combination of flavors. It’s quick, delicious, and can be easily adjusted to be sweeter, spicier, or both – whatever you like!

So, what is Mexican hot chocolate?

The practice of blending chocolate and chili peppers can be traced back to the ancient Maya, Atzec, and Olmec civilizations, which share the same territory as modern day Mexico. Back then, chocolate drinks were often prepared for significant events such as harvests, battles, and celebrations.

Known as chocolhaa (“bitter water”) by the Mayans and Xocolatl by the Aztecs, it usually consisted of ground cacao beans, chili peppers and water.

Over time additional ingredients were introduced – warming cinnamon, vanilla, and of course sugar – to create the delicious blend known as Mexican hot chocolate.

Although traditional Mexican hot chocolate tends to be a little grainy due to the use of ground cacao beans, I prefer to use 70% dark chocolate for a smoother finish. The result is a decadent, lightly sweetened cup of deliciousness. If you’re adding homemade marshmallows or whipped cream the sweetness level is probably just about right, but if not you may want to add a little extra sweetener to taste.

During preparation, Mexican hot chocolate is usually stirred with a molinillo (unique wooden whisk) to combine ingredients and whip in a little air, but I don’t have one so I use an immersion blender or milk frother instead. A regular whisk will work, too.

Whatever method you choose, I hope you love this recipe as much as we do.

Looking for more cold weather deliciousness? Try these recipes . . .

Hot Apple Cider Recipe–Making homemade apple cider from scratch is so much easier than you might think. All you need are fresh apples, spices, water, and a few slices of orange if you have them on hand. This recipe is a kid-favorite, and can also serve as the base for hot buttered rum.

Masala Chai Mix–This masala chai mix is warming, balanced in flavor, and ready in under five minutes. I stir it into black tea to make an “instant” chai powder that doesn’t require a long steeping time or the need to strain loose tea and spices, bake it into warm cookies, and even add it to home-churned ice cream.

Eggnog Latte Recipe -This latte is based on my homemade eggnog recipe, but I’ve tweaked things a bit to help the flavor blend better with coffee.

Hot Chocolate Mix –If you prefer American-style hot cocoa, this is the recipe for you.